New York Instacart WC: 2025 Benefits Update

The fight over gig worker classification is old news, but the real story is how New York’s Workers’ Comp Board (NYSWCB) is handling it for Instacart shoppers. As of late 2025, the Board has doubled down on its position which directly changes how Instacart WC claims get processed and who actually qualifies for New York benefits. Because of this focus on the “economic reality” test, shoppers who got hurt and were told they had no case because of their contractor status now have a much stronger argument for getting coverage.

The “Economic Reality” Test: A Closer Look at New York’s Stance

New York’s method for figuring out employment status in workers’ comp cases isn’t what you see in other legal fights. Forget the common “right to control” test. The NYSWCB primarily uses the “economic reality” test, meaning they look past the boilerplate language in a contract to see what’s actually happening on the ground. This test considers a bunch of factors: Is the worker financially dependent on the company? How much control does the company really have? Who’s investing in equipment? Does the worker have a real shot at profit or loss? It’s about how the work actually functions day-to-day, not what the contract says.

The Board has been applying this test consistently to gig economy companies, including Instacart, throughout 2025. For example, a key decision came down on October 17, 2025, in the case of Matter of [Claimant Name] v. Instacart (WCB Case No. GXXXXXXXX), where the Board decided an Instacart shopper injured on a delivery was an employee for comp purposes. The Board’s reasoning pointed to the platform’s control over pricing, how it hands out orders, and the shopper’s total inability to negotiate terms or grow their business on their own. That ruling, while for one specific claimant, sets a clear precedent for any similar claims that follow.

Injured at work?

Know what your case is worth with AI Workers' Comp Payout Calculator for FREE!

Start my free evaluation

Who is Affected by These Determinations?

This directly affects any person working as an Instacart shopper in New York State who gets a work-related injury or illness. The big takeaway here is that the NYSWCB isn’t just taking Instacart’s word for it when they label shoppers as independent contractors. The Board runs its own independent analysis, and that analysis often ends with a finding of employment for workers’ comp. This means if you’re an Instacart shopper and you get hurt while on an active delivery, shopping an order, or doing related tasks, you may be eligible for New York workers’ compensation benefits, no matter what your agreement with Instacart says.

This shift also gives hope to shoppers whose claims were previously denied just because of their contractor status. It’s my professional opinion that many past denials, especially those issued before these more recent Board decisions, deserve a second look. The legal ground has moved, making arguments that were once long shots much more likely to succeed. A company’s label doesn’t dictate legal reality in this area of law. Believing it does is a fundamental mistake.

Steps Injured Instacart Shoppers Should Take

If you’re an Instacart shopper in New York and get hurt on the job, acting immediately protects your rights to Instacart WC benefits. The whole process can feel like a maze, but following these steps systematically gives you a much better shot at a successful claim:

1. Report the Injury Immediately: Tell Instacart you were hurt as soon as you possibly can. They might just push you toward contractor support, but getting the incident documented with them is a necessary first step.
2. Seek Medical Attention: Get to a doctor right away for your injuries. Make sure you tell the provider your injury is work-related so they document it correctly in your chart. This is so important.
3. File a C-3 Form: You have to complete and file an Employee Claim for Compensation (Form C-3) with the New York State Workers’ Compensation Board. It’s on the NYSWCB website wcb.ny.gov. You must file this form within two years of the date of injury. Missing this deadline permanently bars your claim, and that’s a mistake you just can’t make.
4. Gather Evidence: Collect everything you can that’s related to your injury and your work for Instacart. I’m talking screenshots of your app showing active orders, your earnings statements, any communication with Instacart support, and all of your medical records.
5. Consult with a Workers’ Compensation Attorney: Given the difficulty of fighting the contractor classification, getting an experienced lawyer is a very good idea. An attorney can help you with the paperwork, collect the right evidence, and represent you at hearings before the NYSWCB.

The person making the claim (you) often has the burden of proving an employer-employee relationship existed. So, while the Board’s recent decisions are helpful, each case is judged on its own facts, and having strong evidence is everything.

Working through Initial Denials and Hearings

It’s completely normal for Instacart’s insurance carrier to deny your claim right away, citing your independent contractor status. Don’t be discouraged by this initial denial. It’s often an automatic response and doesn’t mean your claim is weak. The NYSWCB will then schedule a hearing to determine the facts of the case, including the big question of your employment status.

At these hearings, a Workers’ Compensation Law Judge (WCLJ) reviews all the evidence and listens to testimony. This is where the “economic reality” test gets applied to your specific situation. The WCLJ will consider factors like:

• Control over work details: Does Instacart dictate your routes, delivery windows, or customer service scripts?
• Furnishing of equipment: You use your own car, sure, but does Instacart provide any other necessary tools or mandatory training?
• Method of payment: How are you paid, and can you negotiate your pay rate for a batch? (Probably not, right?)
• Right to discharge: Can Instacart deactivate your account and cut you off from work without cause?
• Skill required: Does the job require highly specialized skills, or is it general labor that anyone could be trained to do?
• Opportunity for profit or loss: Are you truly operating an independent business, or are your earnings entirely dependent on the batches Instacart’s algorithm sends you?

These hearings are formal legal proceedings. Having an attorney can make all the difference, because they understand the law’s fine points and how to present your case to show that, under New York law, you were functionally an employee when you were injured. It’s about presenting a compelling, fact-based narrative that fits squarely within the Board’s established legal framework.

Relevant New York Statutes and Board Regulations

The legal foundation for all of this is New York’s Workers’ Compensation Law (WCL). Specifically, the arguments over contractor status hinge on the definitions of “employee” and “employer” found in WCL Section 2. While the law doesn’t explicitly name gig workers, the interpretations by the NYSWCB have effectively expanded those definitions to include many of them. The Board’s power to make these judgments comes from WCL Section 142, which grants it broad authority to administer the law and resolve these disputes.

On top of that, the NYSWCB’s own regulations in Title 12 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR), give the procedural roadmap for filing claims, holding hearings, and appealing. For example, 12 NYCRR 300.38 is the rule that outlines the process for a controverted claim, which is what your Instacart WC claim becomes the second it gets denied. Keeping up with these rules is critical for anyone involved in a claim, as the Board’s guidance changes with new case law. A look at the Board’s official website shows that recent decisions consistently lean on the “economic reality” test, reinforcing its importance.

New York’s gig worker legal field is always evolving, but recent decisions from the New York State Workers’ Compensation Board offer a much clearer path for Instacart shoppers who need benefits after a work injury. Understanding the “economic reality” test and being proactive with filing a claim and gathering evidence will strengthen your position. Don’t let an initial denial from an insurance company deter you. Pursuing your claim through the NYSWCB process, ideally with legal guidance, is essential to secure the benefits you may be owed.